Nithya Raman gained a spot on the Los Angeles Metropolis Council 4 years in the past by promising to ease the town’s homelessness disaster.
Now, the council member factors to her work lowering the variety of folks residing on the road in her Silver Lake-to-Reseda district as she runs for reelection.
Los Angeles Homeless Companies Authority knowledge present “unsheltered homelessness” dropped 7% in her district over a two-year interval. The time period contains anybody residing within the open or in a tent or automobile.
Councilmember Kevin de León can also be waging a reelection marketing campaign and sending out mailers asserting that homelessness dropped in his district.
Unsheltered homelessness dropped 7% in his Northeast L.A. district final 12 months, based on unofficial LAHSA outcomes.
Raman and De León aren’t considered as buddies or political allies. However each are in the identical boat: waging a tricky reelection marketing campaign whereas touting progress of their districts on homelessness.
Such a message can bolster a marketing campaign in a metropolis the place polls present that homelessness is the No. 1 problem. Political marketing consultant Brian Van Riper mentioned voters will even weigh the town’s success on how they really feel strolling round their neighborhoods and whether or not there are indicators of homelessness.
“Voters vote as a lot on feeling and emotion as they do on statistic and truth,” mentioned Van Riper, who isn’t concerned within the race.
Two components make it onerous this election 12 months to trace Metropolis Corridor’s progress on the disaster.
Some Metropolis Council district boundaries have been modified considerably following the town’s 2021 redistricting course of.
On the identical time, the L.A. Homeless Companies Authority, the town and county company that oversees homelessness, didn’t launch council district-specific homelessness numbers in 2023.
Unsheltered homelessness grew 15% in Los Angeles in 2023 in contrast with 2022, based on LAHSA. For the reason that 2015 depend, general homelessness has elevated by 80% within the metropolis.
Jason Ward, an economist on the Santa Monica-based Rand Corp., a nonprofit analysis institute, has been learning homelessness in Hollywood, Skid Row and Venice since 2021.
He mentioned it’s “most likely cheap” to infer that the variety of citywide encampments has declined given the assorted packages underway, together with Mayor Karen Bass’ Inside Protected program, which locations folks into lodge and motel rooms.
“Even in Skid Row, there’s a moderation and a flat pool of individuals, quite than an upward pattern,” he mentioned.
On a windy morning in Could 2023 two staffers from Raman’s workplace joined homelessness outreach staff to go to a collection of ragged tents alongside the L.A. River’s concrete banks.
The group was there to introduce themselves, a part of the method of making an attempt to coax folks to maneuver into shelters.
Aides to L.A. Councilmember Nithya Raman joined outreach staff in Could 2023 making contact with homeless residents residing alongside the L.A. River, together with Christopher Given, left.
(Francine Orr/Los Angeles Occasions)
This system, launched with state and federal funds, is likely one of the ways in which Raman’s workplace has moved greater than 500 folks in her district into shelter, based on her workplace.
Greater than a dozen main encampments in Raman’s district, together with a hall of RVs alongside Victory Boulevard in Reseda, have been cleared, based on her workplace.
Month-to-month neighborhood occasions for the unhoused hosted by Raman’s workplace provide haircuts, showers, and entry to identification playing cards and shelter.
Raman, who chairs the council’s homelessness committee, mentioned the work by her crew exhibits that the town “can truly tackle avenue homelessness, which is what most Angelenos are involved about, much more successfully than we now have been up to now.”
Former Councilmember Mike Bonin mentioned that many council workplaces have outreach groups however Raman’s employees acts as “housing navigators.”
“She has of us who’re on the market who’re constructing relationships over time and determining what kind of housing folks want,” Bonin mentioned.
Alex Perez will get a haircut in December on the Will and Ariel Durant Department Library in Hollywood — a service that’s a part of month-to-month occasions held in Raman’s council district.
(Myung J. Chun/Los Angeles Occasions)
The 7% drop within the unsheltered homeless inhabitants in Raman’s district was in 2022, in contrast with 2020. (LAHSA didn’t conduct a depend in 2021 due to COVID-19). On the identical time, the sheltered inhabitants greater than doubled throughout that interval.
Raman’s workplace credit the rise in sheltered inhabitants to extra beds being supplied by her district. These in shelter, similar to motel rooms, are nonetheless thought-about homeless by the town.
LAHSA’s 2022 numbers didn’t have in mind the town’s current redistricting course of that affected Raman’s district. She misplaced some 40% of her constituents as Hancock Park, Park La Brea and different neighborhoods have been eliminated, and Encino and Reseda have been added to her district.
Put up-redistricting, LAHSA’s unofficial 2023 knowledge confirmed that Raman’s district once more noticed a 7% drop in unsheltered homelessness in contrast with 2022’s depend. However given the dramatic change in her district boundaries, it’s tough to check the 2 years meaningfully.
The 2023 determine comes from uncooked knowledge collected by LAHSA that was reviewed by The Occasions. The districts led by Raman and De León have been amongst six districts that noticed drops in unsheltered homeless populations, based on that knowledge.
LAHSA didn’t launch official council district-level knowledge in 2023 due to considerations that the numbers weren’t exact, mentioned LAHSA spokesperson Ahmad Chapman.
Raman’s challengers in Tuesday’s major — Deputy Metropolis Atty. Ethan Weaver and software program engineer Levon “Lev” Baronian — each provide voters a special method on homelessness.
Each mentioned they’d implement Municipal Code 41.18, the town’s anti-camping legislation, which permits police to control the place folks can sit and sleep and is opposed by Raman.
Weaver has additionally criticized Raman’s dealing with of encampments round Cahuenga Boulevard and the Los Feliz Bridge Dwelling shelter. Neighbors have complained about security and sanitation at each places.
He additionally desires a phased withdrawal from LAHSA. The company, which is ruled by a 10-member board, was “designed to fail,” he mentioned. “In case you speak to any of our council members, they’ll inform you that they can’t give direct orders to this paperwork.”
Raman has argued towards a pullout from LAHSA, saying such a transfer would jeopardize federal funding meant to assist the town’s unhoused inhabitants.
Since taking workplace in 2020, De León has opened three tiny residence villages — in Eagle Rock, Highland Park and Boyle Heights— transformed two motels into momentary housing in El Sereno, and accomplished a 77-bed shelter for ladies and households in Boyle Heights.
Greater than 2,000 beds have been created in his district, based on his workplace.
De León mentioned he pursued housing choices whilst he was the goal of recall makes an attempt, a few of them pushed by opposition to his push for interim homeless housing.
Councilmember Kevin De León greets folks in line for a meals distribution outdoors his workplace in Eagle Rock.
(Christina Home/Los Angeles Occasions)
“I’ve constructed [homeless] housing in each a part of my district and I’ve constructed various kinds of housing as a result of there’s no single resolution to the disaster,” De León mentioned in an interview.
Tommy Newman, vp of public affairs at United Method of Better L.A., mentioned that Northeast L.A. has traditionally lacked shelter choices, so it’s “good to see” De León’s push so as to add beds.
On a current morning, the council member inspected an alley in an industrial space of Boyle Heights the place his workplace was in search of to get folks into housing.
De León and Los Angeles Police Division Senior Lead Officer Johnny Altamirano described how thieves rent unhoused folks residing in tents to strip copper wire.
The thieves pay folks with crystal meth, a cycle that retains the unhoused folks on this space “drugged up,” mentioned the councilman, who desires extra L.A. County assets to assist homeless residents battle drug dependancy.
E-newsletter
Get the lowdown on L.A. politics
Join our L.A. Metropolis Corridor publication to get weekly insights, scoops and evaluation.
You could sometimes obtain promotional content material from the Los Angeles Occasions.
In marketing campaign mailers, De León says homelessness declined in District 14, which takes in Skid Row and half or all of Boyle Heights, Lincoln Heights, Eagle Rock, El Sereno and Hermon.
The unofficial 2023 knowledge from LAHSA present that the unsheltered inhabitants within the district dropped 7% final 12 months in contrast with 2022.
De León spokesperson Pete Brown mentioned LAHSA supplied numbers to the council member’s workplace exhibiting a slight lower in District 14’s general homelessness final 12 months. LAHSA’s Chapman mentioned that knowledge was imprecise.
A number of the seven folks difficult De León within the major level to LAHSA’s 2022 knowledge.
Unsheltered homelessness rose that 12 months 38% in contrast with 2020, mentioned one of many candidates, Assemblymember Miguel Santiago (D-Los Angeles).
Kevin de León goes over his speech notes earlier than opening of Arroyo Seco Tiny Dwelling Village on Oct. 21, 2021.
(Irfan Khan/Los Angeles Occasions)
“Clearly, regardless of the incumbent has been doing isn’t sufficient,” Santiago mentioned.
One other candidate, tenant rights legal professional Ysabel Jurado, proposes neighborhood useful resource facilities to supply sanitation, healthcare and social companies for unhoused folks.
Occasions employees writers David Zahniser and Doug Smith contributed to this report.
