Small drones have turn into a typical sight on right this moment’s battlefields, prized for his or her comparatively low value, ease of use, and world availability. Whereas client and hobby-kit-type drones first began making headlines from battle zones within the early 2010s, they arguably had their coming-of-age second in early 2022, after Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine.
As Ukrainians leapt into motion to withstand, they instantly referred to as upon almost a decade of expertise with these low-cost and easy-to-use aerial platforms. They used them in tandem with far more complicated (and costly) navy drone applied sciences, each produced in Ukraine and overseas. Russian fighters shortly adopted, acquiring and constructing their very own client drones with assistance from volunteer networks coordinated on Telegram.
As drones shortly overtook the skies above the Ukrainian battlefield, media each shot by and about drones unfold on-line. Open supply analysts on Telegram, Twitter, and TikTok quickly discovered themselves combing via a sea of dramatic, ultra-high-resolution movies and images, giving them traditionally unprecedented entry to the day-to-day workings of recent warfare.
A considerable amount of the drone footage from Ukraine seems to have been shot by small, comparatively cheap client and custom-built drones, per our observations since Russia’s invasion of the nation in early 2022. This marks a big change from what we noticed throughout earlier conflicts, by which many of the drone footage out there to open supply researchers gave the impression to be collected by bigger, extra subtle, and longer-range navy drones equivalent to, most famously, the Turkish-produced Bayraktar TB2. Because the rise of small, broadly out there drones as a prolific supply of high-resolution open supply footage remains to be a comparatively new phenomenon, this information will focus totally on figuring out these plane.
The drone footage supplies a wealth of data which will not be instantly apparent to analysts, equivalent to helpful clues in regards to the applied sciences out there to totally different events in an armed battle. To find out the origin of drone footage, you may search for hints in imagery taken by the drone itself, as totally different makes and fashions carry totally different sensors, have totally different flight traits, and are used for various missions and functions. Right here, we’ll give attention to the drone platforms we’ve come throughout most frequently in open supply analysis, primarily within the full-scale Russian invasion of Ukraine, from which probably the most related materials exists.
Drone-world variety signifies that, with follow, analysts can decide if a given video was extra prone to have been shot by a client quadcopter like a DJI Mavic 3 (which captures ultra-crisp stabilised footage, has a zoom digicam, and might hover in place for prolonged durations), or by a bigger, airplane-shaped aerial autos like Ukraine’s locally-made Leleka-100 surveillance drone (which flies at a lot larger altitudes and for for much longer durations, has a much less high-quality digicam, and strikes in a really totally different, “jerkier” method than the Mavic).
Right here’s an instance of footage shot by a Ukrainian-piloted DJI Mavic 3 Professional, because it steals a dropped radio from Russian forces:
Evaluate it with this footage shot by a Ukrainian Leleka-100, as verified by The Washington Put up:
Whereas there are noticeable variations, it’s nonetheless very arduous to make a exact drone identification, versus guess of the final drone kind, just by uncooked drone footage. The exception to this rule is in the event you’re fortunate sufficient to be reviewing comparatively unusual footage the place tell-tale elements of the drone’s physique cross the sector of view of the digicam.
This shortcoming is why drone software program person interfaces or on-screen shows (OSDs) is useful.
Like specialised navy drones, nearly all client and custom-built drones available on the market right this moment can stream what the drone “sees” in actual time again to an utility run from a tool on the bottom. These purposes and interfaces are clearly visually distinct from each other. On the identical time, drone video from fight is commonly recorded by a tool impartial from the system it’s being streamed to, that means we will clearly see what software program is getting used.
Among the technical specs detailed on this article might change over time, however the level above stays constant: a familiarity with drone streaming software program is vital. On the finish of this information you’ll discover a hyperlink to our Google Doc the place we’ll extra repeatedly replace details about drone shows, linking to the person manuals on producers’ web sites.
So, how can we put this information into follow? Beneath, we clarify how open supply researchers can establish a number of client and non-consumer drones primarily based on footage.
Figuring out Client Drones
Within the early 2010s, mannequin airplane and helicopter hobbyists took word of current advances in miniaturized sensors and microprocessors (largely made in China) and commenced experimenting with making their small plane a lot “smarter” than they’d ever been earlier than.
With the addition of a computerized flight-controller “mind” able to controlling a number of rotors directly and GPS-supported stabilization, previously hard-to-fly mannequin helicopters grew to become simply controllable even by amateurs. Quickly, these previously ultra-niche plane have been carrying high-resolution stabilized cameras, navigating to pre-set waypoints, creating extremely correct maps, and avoiding obstacles with assistance from sensors. They have been additionally being offered to the general public at inexpensive costs at electronics shops worldwide. Fighters in world conflicts shortly started to discover the probabilities.
Beneath we define among the hottest drone producers whose drones are at present utilized in battle zones, and the way their fashions could be recognized primarily based on footage.
Shenzhen Da-Jiang Improvements (DJI)
Shenzhen Da-Jiang Improvements (DJI), a Chinese language firm, is the world’s largest producer of client drones, a market that they’ve dominated for over a decade. After Russia invaded Ukraine in early 2022, combatants on each sides of the battle started utilizing DJI merchandise in large numbers, with the Matrice sequence and Mavic sequence being probably the most sought-after, for duties starting from accumulating data, concentrating on artillery, and dropping small explosives. We are able to try to establish totally different DJI drone fashions by analyzing screenshots for small visible variations from plane to plane.
This footage is mostly accessed through DJI Fly, a well-liked smartphone and pill utility developed by the corporate to be used with its numerous drone fashions:
DJI Fly
A preferred smartphone and pill app, suitable with:
- Mavic Air 2, 2S, 3
- Mavic 3, 3 Professional, 3 Traditional
- (Mavic) Mini sequence
Let’s stroll via an instance of how open supply analysts can use DJI apps to establish totally different drones.
On November sixteenth, 2023, an X person who goes by the alias Kriegsforscher (German for “struggle researcher”) and claims to be a member of the Ukrainian Marine Corps posted a “quick replace about enemy advance close to Vodiane, south of Avdiivka.” His first publish within the thread included 4 aerial pictures of destroyed tanks.
Take a more in-depth have a look at the primary {photograph} within the sequence.
We start by making the educated guess that the footage was in all probability shot with a model of the DJI Mavic, primarily based on our information that the Mavic sequence is the most well-liked client drone in Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
However which Mavic? Should you have a look at the best of the picture, you’ll discover a small field with “7.0x” written in it. We all know from reviewing product specs on the DJI web site that the DJI Mavic 3 is the one Mavic mannequin that’s able to zooming to that extent, because of its in-built telephoto lens.
There’s one other attention-grabbing clue on this picture: word the yellow binoculars showing within the sq. on the best.
We all know that on Could thirty first, 2022, DJI pushed out a DJI Fly app replace that eliminated the yellow binoculars for “Discover” mode fully, switching to a brand new person interface. Since we will see the binoculars, that offers us some extra helpful data: this drone is operating software program that hasn’t been up to date since a minimum of Could 2022.
Whereas it’s doable this account is solely posting previous footage, one other clarification is that fighters can deliberately keep away from updating drone software program to stop updates from producers that disable sure hacks and tweaks they use to make their plane more durable to find by the enemy. Particularly, hacks aimed to disable Aeroscope performance within the drones. With this in thoughts, we will guess the drone may have been hacked or modified ultimately, prone to keep away from detection by CUAS (counter-UAS) gear, utilizing the sooner exploits which have been out there shortly after Russia’s full-scale invasion started. Today, because of developments in firmware/{hardware} modification, DJI FLY app model isn’t related.
DJI Go 4
This DJI utility is suitable with older, extra professionally targeted DJI drone fashions, together with the:
- Mavic 2 Professional/Zoom
- Encourage 2
- Matrice sequence.
An instance of the DJI GO 4 person interface:
Within the screenshot under, pulled from a video uploaded to Telegram on October tenth by Qassam Brigades, the militant wing of Hamas, it’s instantly visually obvious that the footage was shot with a DJI drone as a result of app person interface’s distinctive design. However which DJI drone?
Whereas DJI has launched a number of variations of its drone flight management apps, I observed that the app seen on this screenshot most resembled the interface seen on this shot uploaded by a YouTube person with a DJI Mavic 2 Zoom drone, which solely works with the DJI GO 4 app (in addition to this footage uploaded by one other person). I additionally observed the shaded zoom bar on the best of the display within the YouTube footage matches the Hamas footage: which means the drone flown by Hamas seems to have zoom functionality.
We’re additionally capable of decide that the footage was shot by a DJI drone that has been modified to drop explosives. Observe the 2 packing containers on the higher left of the primary screenshot, warning the pilot that impediment avoidance is disabled and that the auxiliary backside mild has been turned on. The favored DJI drone dropper variations utilized by fighters around the globe – which could be bought on-line, and are sometimes marketed to fishermen to drop bait – are managed by flicking the swap that controls the sunshine on the underside of the drone on the drone’s controller.
While you see these auxiliary mild warnings, (equivalent to in this extra DJI Mavic instance posted by a Russian navy blogger on Telegram) which means the drone is probably going getting used for bombing assaults: this additionally signifies that the auxiliary mild warning is acritical drone identification clue. There is just one DJI drone with zoom functionality, a backside auxiliary mild, and works with the DJI GO 4 app: the DJI Mavic 2 Zoom.
DJI Pilot
Geared in the direction of skilled, or enterprise, pilots, this app is suitable with these drones (amongst others):
- Matrice 30 and 30T
- Mavic 3T and 3E.
The footage under, posted by the well-known Russian open supply account Rvoenkor on Telegram on November eleventh 2023, seems to be drone video of fight on the bottom. The poster presents this description of the motion (machine-translated): “veterans of the Wagner PMC who transferred to the RF Armed Forces are adjusting artillery hearth on enemy positions.” Moreover, the poster notes that they’re trying to purchase an Autel 4T drone to be used by troopers in Russia – but additionally mentions “altering” over to a Matrice 30T.
Due to this fact, we have now two widespread client drones talked about by identify within the publish: however have been both of those drones truly used to seize the footage?
Instantly, we will rule out the Autel 4T because the app interface seen in each movies doesn’t resemble the Autel Explorer app (as seen in a screenshot pulled from this supply under). Nevertheless, the app interface doesn’t fairly match the DJI Fly design we checked out within the different examples, both.
If we return to the footage, word that one of many movies, on the best, is in black and white and seems to be shot with an infrared digicam at night-time. This narrows the probabilities down: we all know that we’re in search of a drone that has an infrared sensor, and is not suitable with the DJI Fly app. Each these descriptions match the DJI Matrice 30 sequence of drones.
Subsequent, we navigate to DJI’s obtain web page, and seek the advice of the DJI Matrice 30 guide. There, we discover that the DJI Matrice 30 is barely suitable with the DJI Pilot 2 app, meant for enterprise customers – an app that’s not truly listed on DJI’s principal obtain web page, and whose existence may be straightforward to overlook in the event you didn’t seek the advice of the precise documentation for the DJI Matrice 30.
Within the DJI guide, we discover a screenshot that seems to be a superb match for the person interface seen on this screenshot, describing the Thermal Digicam View menu out there to the DJI Matrice 30T drone sequence. Based mostly on this proof, we will make an informed guess that the video on the best within the unique publish was certainly shot with a DJI Matrice 30T drone. Though the video on the left is extra aggressively cropped, making it more durable to see the person interface, we will additionally make the knowledgeable guess that it was shot with the identical drone, utilizing the plane’s different, non-thermal sensor.
The Rival: Autel
Autel’s client drones are the second-most standard client various to DJI merchandise seen throughout Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, and are used sometimes in different conflicts as effectively. Their Autel Evo line of drones characteristic high-quality sensors and an identical compact, moveable design to DJI’s drones, though they aren’t produced in as large numbers as DJI merchandise, and aren’t suitable with the identical variety of firmware hacks, like Russia’s very talked-about “1001” hack used to safe DJI merchandise. Autel drones use totally different software program than DJI drones, and could be visually recognized from footage by this system.
In one other real-world instance, this nonetheless from a video posted by Russian state media reveals a display with the Autel Enterprise app operating. Observe the visible variations between this app and the DJI app sequence.
This matches completely with the Autel Enterprise, which is barely suitable with Autel Max 4T. Russians have additionally re-skinned the Autel MAX 4T beneath the “Patriot” model identify – in an effort to make their small-drone manufacturing business appear extra strong than it truly is.
Figuring out Non-Client Drones
Though footage captured by client and DIY FPV drones makes up nearly all of what’s out there to open supply analysts on social media right this moment, footage from different drone varieties additionally repeatedly circulates on-line. Listed below are some examples.
Aerorozvidka R-18
First based in 2014 by beginner Ukrainian drone fans desirous to repel the sooner Russian invasion, Aerorozvidka is now one of many nation’s most outstanding producers of drones, contributing each plane and pilots to the struggle effort. Aerorozvidka made headlines round the world early on within the 2022 Russian invasion, after it was revealed that their custom-built eight-armed R-18 “octocopter,” able to lifting heavy explosive masses, performed a big function in slowing down the progress of a Russian column headed for Kyiv. Whereas Aerorozvidka additionally makes use of client drones as effectively, the group continues to construct and to make use of extra personalized plane (together with small FPV “kamikaze” drones) – and posts a gentle stream of aerial struggle footage to its social media accounts.
Whereas there isn’t any really tell-tale signal that you just’re Aerorozvidka R-18 footage, this mixture of options makes it extra doubtless:
- Regular, “floating” motion much like that of different multirotor drones.
- Use of a thermal sensor.
- The drone seems to be dropping notably giant/heavy payloads.
- Primary on-screen show (OSD) interface, as seen within the screenshot under.
Switchblade
Produced by AeroVironment, a US navy contractor, Switchblades are subtle (and costly) self-destroying plane, able to robotically destroying targets. The Switchblade 600 is a more moderen, bigger model of the Switchblade 300. On this instance of the Switchblade 600 in motion, launched by Ukrainian sources in October 2023, you may clearly see the comparatively grainy and characteristically “wobbly” footage shot by the drone’s digicam.
FPV (First Particular person View) Drones
A typical sight on social media networks devoted to fashionable battle is first-person view (FPV) drone video footage. This footage is captured by low-cost, super-fast, and short-range drones which can be largely hand-built utilizing cheap digital parts sourced primarily from China. Piloting these nimble plane requires exact distant management inputs, and so pilots sometimes put on a headset that shows the view from the drone’s onboard digicam, therefore the nickname “First Particular person View”.
Navigating through headset means FPV footage typically incorporates a vast field-of-view picture with barrel distortion, in any other case generally known as the fisheye impact, making it a simple strategy to establish photographs from these drones.
One other strategy to establish FPV drones is through their on-screen shows (OSDs) which builders configure to indicate the pilot key details about the flight and system on high of the video sign. Relying on the OSD configuration, totally different information fields will seem that may permit open supply researchers to establish that the footage they’re got here from an FPV drone. For instance, some of the generally used shows is Betaflight’s inner OSD, and there are many others that can be utilized to establish these drone sorts.
Aside from fisheye view, listed here are another clues indicating that you just’re FPV one-way drone footage, and what you may study from it:
- “TV noise,” resulting from poor sign transmission on fast-moving FPV quadcopters.
- “Low battery” / “Land now” indicators on the display show.
- Voltage indicators for battery life, or dBm signalling transmission energy.
- Lack of a monitoring crosshair within the footage: FPV drone pilots should manually fly to the goal, often with none software-aided monitoring.
- The flight sample shouldn’t be a straight line: reasonably the drone strikes to the left or proper with none outlined route, in a “wiggly” sample, reasonably than a floating one.
- Wires are seen in entrance of the drone within the video: these are used to set off the explosive payload. Alternately, the payload itself is seen, as it’s going to detonate on affect.
- Props are seen within the body, often on either side.
Contemplate the under instance from a video posted to Telegram by Ukrainian troopers within the “ESCADRONE” FPV unit. Now we have made some annotations to assist visualize among the tell-tale indicators of footage shot on FPV drones.
Right here is one other screenshot instance posted by a outstanding Ukrainian vlogger, who organizes crowdfunding drives to supply FPV drones for the Ukrainian military.
The OSD on this instance is configured to output extra data. The heading is on the high: on the highest proper, you may see numerous uncooked sign energy (RSSI) measurements.
Small drones have confirmed themselves to be a key device on the battlefield, and it appears inevitable that they’ll turn into much more standard within the wars of the longer term. Extra so than many different applied sciences utilized in warfare, drone tech is in a continuing state of flux, as pilots and engineers always work to provide you with new concepts and new methods, locked in an aerial sport of cat-and-mouse.
As they evaluation the drone-collected imagery steaming out of current and future wars, open supply analysts ought to do not forget that change is the one fixed on the subject of unmanned aerial autos.
To entry a repeatedly up to date listing of drone shows, together with supply hyperlinks to the producers’ person manuals, view the authors’ public Google Doc right here.
The authors have additionally compiled an inventory of incidents involving drones in Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine, together with in depth examples of footage filmed by drones. This public Google Spreadsheet could be accessed right here.
Bellingcat is a non-profit and the power to hold out our work depends on the sort help of particular person donors. If you need to help our work, you are able to do so right here. You can even subscribe to our Patreon channel right here. Subscribe to our Publication and comply with us on Instagram right here, X right here and Mastodon right here.
