The prices to defend Los Angeles County — and its military of sheriff’s deputies, firefighters, social employees and medical doctors — in opposition to lawsuits skyrocketed within the final fiscal yr, in keeping with twin experiences launched this week.
The annual tally of the county’s authorized tab, which tracks payouts made between July 1, 2022, and June 30, 2023, discovered the county spent $257 million on settlements and judgments — triple what it spent the yr earlier than.
The associated fee to defend the Sheriff’s Division, which settled a slew of big-dollar instances, ballooned to $150 million — roughly double what it had price the yr earlier than.
And the quantity the county spent on general claims — together with employee compensation instances and associated authorized charges — was greater than $982 million. That’s about 2% of the county’s working price range — and greater than the county budgeted this yr for its animal care and management division, district lawyer and public defender mixed.
County officers level to a number of components contributing to the dramatic rise in litigation spending: the growing prices of hiring exterior legal professionals, the decision of instances that stalled through the pandemic and a run of extraordinarily pricey settlements, many stemming from alleged misconduct throughout the Sheriff’s Division.
Of the highest 13 settlements, 10 concerned the Sheriff’s Division.
“Once more, L.A. County taxpayers are having to foot the invoice for the sheriff on legislation enforcement negligence,” stated Megan Castillo, a coordinator for the Reimagine LA Coalition, which advocates for options to incarceration.
One of many heftiest litigation prices final yr stemmed from a lawsuit initially filed in 2010 over strip search practices within the ladies’s jail, the place deputies routinely pressured feminine inmates to reveal their genitals in massive teams throughout mass strip searches.
In 2019, the courtroom accredited a $53-million settlement on behalf of 87,937 ladies who had been searched a complete of 421,718 instances between March 2008 and January 2015.
The Occasions beforehand reported that it was then the most important settlement payout on report in county historical past, although the county didn’t admit wrongdoing. The Sheriff’s Division stopped routinely strip-searching feminine inmates in April 2016, when it started counting on physique scanners for screening.
The payout included within the county’s litigation report — greater than $17 million — was the second of three installments agreed to in courtroom.
One other colossal payout centered on a high-profile case: the helicopter crash that killed basketball star Kobe Bryant, his daughter and 7 others.
After the 2020 wreck, reporting by The Occasions confirmed that a number of sheriff’s deputies and firefighters had shared graphic photos of the crash scene and the victims’ stays. Then-Sheriff Alex Villanueva admitted eight deputies took or shared pictures, and that he ordered that the photographs be destroyed.
In September 2020, Vanessa Bryant and Chris Chester — whose spouse and daughter died within the crash — filed swimsuit. A jury present in favor of the plaintiffs, and final yr the county agreed to pay practically $20 million to the Chester household and $28.85 million to the Bryant household.
Villanueva, who was nonetheless in workplace for the start of the fiscal yr and through a number of of the incidents that changed into lawsuits, stated the board and varied oversight entities had been accountable for the rising price of litigation due to their “intensive marketing campaign to falsely declare deputy gangs had been operating roughshod” over the Sheriff’s Division.
“Nearly each case filed now involving pressure or detention carries with it an allegation of deputy gang conduct, regardless of no proof to assist it,” Villanueva instructed The Occasions Tuesday in an e mail. “Because of this, any enhance in litigation prices is brought on by the reckless conduct of the Board of Supervisors and their appointees.”
Joanna Schwartz, a professor at UCLA Faculty of Regulation who research police misconduct lawsuits, stated the truth that the county spent $150 million on Sheriff’s Division litigation raises questions on what evaluation the county does after a settlement to make sure taxpayer cash isn’t drained the identical manner subsequent yr.
“What evaluation have they completed to evaluate which stations are extra seemingly than others to be sued or what varieties of allegations usually tend to be the topic of lawsuits?” she stated. “That’s the evaluation that any personal firm that had $150 million in damages levied in opposition to it in the middle of a yr would need to do.”
Departments should fill out “corrective motion plans” after main settlements to analyze whether or not there have been coverage failures that might result in the same incident taking place once more. However Schwartz stated the plans she’s considered appear weak, too fixated on what went flawed in that particular incident slightly than analyzing bigger traits.
“I don’t assume that that evaluation occurs to the diploma that it ought to in Los Angeles County,” she stated.
A spokesperson for the Sheriff’s Division stated the company tries to course-correct after lawsuits.
“Whereas litigation is at all times a priority for the division, we attempt to enhance our coaching, insurance policies, practices, and procedures to mitigate future litigation,” the spokesperson stated, including it’s commonplace for the division to see extra litigation than others on account of its “public security obligations.”
In November 2022 — throughout a single assembly — the Board of Supervisors accredited greater than $47 million in settlements in instances involving misconduct by sheriff’s deputies.
Publication
Get the lowdown on L.A. politics
Join our L.A. Metropolis Corridor e-newsletter to get weekly insights, scoops and evaluation.
You might often obtain promotional content material from the Los Angeles Occasions.
A kind of got here within the case of Andres Guardado, an adolescent who was shot 5 instances within the again by a sheriff’s deputy in 2020, after a quick foot chase in Gardena. His killing sparked protests and a lawsuit, wherein his mother and father alleged sheriff’s deputies had killed him in an try and change into members of a deputy gang.
The lawsuit was settled for $8 million, however the district lawyer’s workplace declined to prosecute both of the deputies concerned. As a substitute, they had been each despatched to federal jail for an unrelated incident earlier that yr, after they kidnapped a skateboarder and tried to border him for a drug cost.
Not less than two of the opposite settlements accredited at that very same 2022 board assembly additionally resulted in hefty payouts however no prison costs for the deputies concerned — a sample that has been criticized by activists and oversight officers who say it permits issues similar to deputy gangs to fester throughout the division.
“No one is being convicted,” stated Helen Jones, a group organizer whose son, John Horton, died in solitary confinement in Males’s Central Jail in 2009. “If they’ll begin convicting these deputies and holding them accountable, it’ll imply much less lawsuits.”
After seeing footage of her son’s corpse splattered with blood, she sued the county and stated she settled for $2 million. She stated there have been by no means prison costs.
